Pagan Book Reviews

Animal-Wise: The Spirit Language and Signs of Nature
Ted Andrews
Dragonhawk Publishing, 1999
438 pages

This is a pretty typical neopagan sequel. Once again, Andrews presents us with a totem animal dictionary with some supporting material. It’s basically Animal Speak all over again, except with new exercises and a whole new slew of animals.

This isn’t necessarily a bad thing. Fans of his work will enjoy the new ideas to work with. And this time he goes into some pretty varied animals, including Mole, Lark, Woolly Caterpillar, and dozens more. As always, his writing is inviting and never confusing, though it is 101 material, of course.

It doesn’t really work as a stand-alone book for a newbie, just because some of the foundational information is in Animal Speak. However, they do complement each other nicely. The cover, again, is rather wannabe Native, but that’s marketing for you–many people still have the idea that totemism is primarily an American indigenous thing.

Four and a half pawprints out of five.

Want to buy this book?

Animal Speak: The Spiritual & Magical Powers of Creatures Great & Small
Ted Andrews
Llewellyn Publications, 1996
383 pages

This is pretty much the classic neopagan totem dictionary. It gets more recommendations to newbies looking for totemic reading material than any other, and there’s good reason for this. It’s a thorough introduction to finding and working with totem animals, and had, at the time of its publication, the most complete listing of animal totems available.

Rather than just sticking to Big, Impressive North American Mammals and Birds, Andrews gives the totemic qualities of mammals, birds, reptiles, amphibians and even insects from around the world. He gives a number of excellent exercises designed to help the practitioner strengthen the bond with hir totem once the connection has been made, and the entire book is written with respect for this relationship.

I do think he sometimes goes overboard on specific details. For example, he makes a bigger deal out of the fact that certain animals have the color red on them instead of blue, and then pulls in the human associations of red. I interpret it instead as red being the best color for attracting a mate or scaring off predators, depending on what animal we’re talking about. But he does rely heavily on interpreting animal behavior, which I think is a much more solid area of study.

I also like that he didn’t pull a Medicine Cards and talk about how he was teaching “genuine Native American totemism” and throwing around “medicine” and “all my relations” and so forth. I have talked to at least one other person whose opinion I respect who thought that Andrews was still a little too much on the side of cultural appropriation, but I think this is still a big improvement over previous (and later) works that try to be “noble savage totemism”.  The cover is probably the worst of it, IMO, but I can see arguments otherwise.

Overall, it’s pretty easy to see why this book is so popular. It’s not the only alternative out there, and a lot of people have tried to copy it. I’d recommend it to beginners along with Yasmine Galenorn’s Totem Magic.

Four and a half pawprints out of five.

Want to buy this book?

Totem Magic: Dance of the Shapeshifter
Yasmine Galenorn
Crossing Press, 2004
224 pages

This is definitely one of the best books on animal magic to come out in recent years. First and foremost, I want to commend Ms. Galenorn for breaking away from the totem animal dictionary format and creating something unique. It’s nice to see an author who trusts the reader to be able to figure out hir relationship to hir totem on hir own.

I’m also really pleased with the wonderful anecdotes that are used to support a variety of spiritual and practical material. I especially liked reading about the spirit who decided to take up residence in an elk skull on the wall, but Galenorn is a wonderful storyteller no matter what she’s talking about. Her writing style flows well and is very accessible without being watered down.

Pretty much my only complaint would be the pre-crafted rituals and spells, though this is more of a personal pet peeve, and other readers will quite likely find them useful, especially newbies. And the pre-crafted material is inventive, rather than being formulaic as in some books on this and other topics.

Four and a half pawprints out of five.

Want to buy this book?

Magical Creatures
Elizabeth Pepper (editor)
The Witches’ Almanac, Ltd., 2000
96 pages

This is a collection of almanac entries on a number of animals from around the world, edited by the creator of the Witches’ Almanac. The variety is nice, rather than just being Big Impressive North American Mammals and Birds. Many, though not all, are “witchy” animals, associated with witchcraft lore. The writing is easy to read and conversational.

It’s not a particularly in-depth book because of its format. The essays are rather brief, and deal a lot with traditional folklore. There’s also not a lot of practical material. It’s basically a small totem animal dictionary, and so would be best for someone who wants to have several different sources to draw from when researching totemic and related traits.

As a collection of essays from the Almanac, it’s good. But as a standalone book, it’s really not worth the $12.00 cover price. There are more complete guides to be had for not much more than that.

Three pawprints out of five.

Want to buy this book?

Animals of the Soul: Sacred Animals of the Oglala Sioux
Joseph Epes Brown
Element Books Ltd., 1997
142 pages

This book is on my Top Ten Most Underappreciated Books on Animal Magic. It’s a wonderful guide to Lakhota totemism, both the structure of it, and why certain animals are considered sacred.

While it isn’t a full treatise on the traditional culture by far, Brown does a good job of explaining the background context for the specific beliefs. The variety of animals described is nice, too. Along with larger animals like Wolf and Deer, Rabbit and the other small animals of the field are also described. The significance of Buffalo to this culture is given particular attention.

There are some surprises, too. Most neopagan totem dictionaries see Deer as a wholly positive animal. However, according to Brown, for the Lakhota Deer is a dual creature being both capable of kind and malignant properties; this is attributed partly to the Deer’s forked horns. Also, Fox is described as the smaller, gentler, more feminine version of Wolf, which rang true for me.

Again, be sure to supplement this book with others on traditional Lakhota culture. But this is an excellent addition to any neopagan totemist’s book shelf.

Five pawprints out of five.

Want to buy this book?

Magical Beasts: Their Powers, Their Contribution and How to Call for Their Help
Marie Bruce
Quantum, 2004
190 pages

This is one of those that’s getting sold. It’s probably perfect for another person, but I wasn’t impressed.

It’s basically an animal magic cookbook. The bulk of it is formulaic spells for different species; I got bored reading them after a while because they were so similar. The format consisted mostly of: Light a few candles, maybe visualize an animal, say a rhyme a few times, and wait for the magic to happen. That’s not bad in and of itself, but there needed to be more variety. There were a few that really stood out, but for the most part it feels like the author was just trying to fill space.

Not only were there no citations, there wasn’t even a bibliography! I want to know where Bruce got her research–like how in the counting corvids rhyme the fact that it has nine verses automatically associates it with the Morrigan. If it’s UPG, fine–but otherwise, I want sources!

The book would have been improved by more lore in proportion to the spells. There’s also a dearth of anecdotes for a lot of these animals–what about her own experiences?

I got annoyed with some of the poli-witch stuff, too–getting all touchy over the term “hag-ridden” is a waste of time, IMO.

Also, “Book of Earth Shadows”? Come on–you can do better than that. The chapter on dragons reads like a D&D manual. And the idea of cat magic depending on the fur color is like saying only red-haired people can work magic.

There are some good parts. Her writing style is superb–there are very few books that are as easy to read and comprehend as this one. And I really enjoyed the discussions of natural history and animal behavior that were interjected–I could tell she’s worked with horses quite a bit. Most writers on animal magic don’t even mention animal psychology. Most impressive

And the spells themselves are nicely written and structured–as I said, they need some variety is all.

Overall, I’d say the book has potential, but needs work. If this had been marketed as an animal spellbook, it would have worked; but instead it seems like it was offered as a more complete guide to animal magic. The book was presented as one thing, ended up being another, and ended up suffering for the split.

Three pawprints out of five.

Want to buy this book?